Longtime iDVD user that I am, I looked for something newer (and supported). Tried miDVD, liked it, wanted more, and bought miDVD Pro. It works as advertised… IF you have the processor and RAM to support it. I think the negative reviews may have come from those who didn’t have a Mac with enough oomph, and that’s understandable. I’m running this on a MacPro with 16 Gb of RAM, with OS X Yosemite, and it works well. Haven’t tried it on something smaller, so we’ll see. I like it, it works, and has enough features compared to miDVD free version to be worth the money. That said, I dearly wish I had the ability to edit the themes, something I adored in iDVD (rest in peace). If the developers read reviews: Please give us the ability to change the fonts in the titles, at least. But overall, it does the deed and I feel satisfied with it.